Review copy was received from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
The Harvey Girl by Dana Stabenow Series: Clare Wright #1
on March 3, 2026
Genres: Mystery, Thriller
Pages: 272
Format: eARC
Source: NetGalley
Goodreads
Amazon, Audible, Libro.fm, Barnes & Noble, Apple



890. Clare Wright, a talented young detective with a surprising past, has just resolved her latest case for the Pinkerton agency when her career takes an unexpected turn for the American frontier.
Fred Harvey, founder of the famous Harvey House hotels, wants to know who is perpetrating the robberies affecting his new enterprise in Montaña Roja, New Mexico, and he needs an undercover agent who can discover the truth.
Disguised as one of Fred's renowned hostesses, the Harvey Girls, Clare must infiltrate both low and high society as she seeks out the culprits. But with the town a hotbed of crime, and with schemes underway that could have implications for the whole nation, she'll need to make sure her derringer is never far away.
I have enjoyed the books of Dana Stabenow for years now. She has a few mystery series set in Alaska. She has some scifi offerings which I haven’t read yet. She has written other books of a historical nature which isn’t usually my thing. But a historical mystery is something I do enjoy.
The Harvey Girl is the first in a new series about Claire Wright. Claire is a Pinkerton agent sent undercover to work as a Harvey girl. Harvey has hired the Pinkerton agency to look into train robberies that are stealing his restaurant supplies. Claire is smart, resourceful and skilled. She goes a little too far a few times though.
The Gilded Age is full of robbers, barrons and wealthy crooks. Women are not treated very well. It’s what the current administration is trying to recreate.
The daily life and investigations of Claire are interesting enough. The pace moves along well enough. There are the train robberies and murders, along with other oddities to figure out. A broad cast of characters is introduced and the foundation for the world is set. I was always engaged while reading. The author pulls together a lot of real characters and historical facts.
However, while there are plenty of information gathered and definite shady people and other crimes identified, the original train robberies are not really solved. I guess it is fair leaving some plot lines open for the series. The ending did not close off the mysteries clearly, but has Claire continuing to work for Harvey and going to Kansas City offices to investigate further.
| Rating Breakdown | |
|---|---|
| Plot | |
| Writing | |
| Characters | |
| Overall: | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
- 🎧 Conspiracy Theory by Phillip Margolin @philmargolin #TheresePlummer @minotaurbooks.bsky.social @macmillanaudio.bsky.social #LoveAudiobooks@MinotaurBooks @MacmillanAudio - November 17, 2026
- Sunday Post – 15 November 2026 @caffeinatedreviewer.com @readingreality.bsky.social @kimbacaffeinate @readingreality - November 15, 2026
- 🎧 The Body in the Bath by Ragnar Jónasson @ragnarjo #Will Tudor @minotaurbooks.bsky.social @macmillanaudio.bsky.social #LoveAudiobooks @MinotaurBooks @MacmillanAudio - November 14, 2026
Reading this book contributed to these challenges:
- 26-COYER








I enjoy books set in this time period, and this sounds like a great start to a series. Lovely review😁
Thanks Tammy. This was an enjoyable read and I always like to think about how realistic it might be. The only thing I found tough was so many open plot lines since it is a series.
This sounds like a solid historical mystery. This author writes in several genres. I’d be interested in checking out the sci-fi offereings.
Most of her books that I have read are mysteries. I bought the audios for the scifi trilogy and plan to try to read and review that this year sometime.
I’ve not read a lot during this period of history, but this story sounds really good.
I really like the concept with the mysteries and the Pinkertons. It’s the Gilded Age though with robber barons like now.
I love the late 1800s and the Pinkertons. Great review!
Thank you Kimberly. I was excited for those reasons and that I have long enjoyed this author’s mysteries.
I’ve really enjoyed this author’s Kate Shugak series and find this intriguing. I’ll have to look for this one!
yes I love the Kate Shugak books. This is set historically in Gilded Age with the Pinkertons which I find interesting.
I wondered if Kansas City would appear in this as I know our connection to the Harvey girls. Great review!
well I can’t say since I don’t know the connection you know. In these books, it is a restaurant serving along the train routes for travelers and those in town.
Just that they had the Harvey restaurant in the Union Station here in Kansas City. And we have the restaurant here still in Union Station.
Sounds like the beginnings of a cool series.
yes I like how it is a different age with things from that era like Harvey girls and Pinkertons.