Review copy was received from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Westside by WM Akers
Published by Harper Voyager on May 7, 2019
Amazon, Audible, Audiobook, Barnes & Noble
A young detective who specializes in “tiny mysteries” finds herself at the center of a massive conspiracy in this beguiling historical fantasy set on Manhattan’s Westside—a peculiar and dangerous neighborhood home to strange magic and stranger residents—that blends the vivid atmosphere of Caleb Carr with the imaginative power of Neil Gaiman.
New York is dying, and the one woman who can save it has smaller things on her mind.
It’s 1921, and a thirteen-mile fence running the length of Broadway splits the island of Manhattan, separating the prosperous Eastside from the Westside—an overgrown wasteland whose hostility to modern technology gives it the flavor of old New York. Thousands have disappeared here, and the respectable have fled, leaving behind the killers, thieves, poets, painters, drunks, and those too poor or desperate to leave.
It is a hellish landscape, and Gilda Carr proudly calls it home.
Slightly built, but with a will of iron, Gilda follows in the footsteps of her late father, a police detective turned private eye. Unlike that larger-than-life man, Gilda solves tiny mysteries: the impossible puzzles that keep us awake at night; the small riddles that destroy us; the questions that spoil marriages, ruin friendships, and curdle joy. Those tiny cases distract her from her grief, and the one impossible question she knows she can’t answer: “How did my father die?”
Yet on Gilda’s Westside, tiny mysteries end in blood—even the case of a missing white leather glove. Mrs. Copeland, a well-to-do Eastside housewife, hires Gilda to find it before her irascible merchant husband learns it is gone. When Gilda witnesses Mr. Copeland’s murder at a Westside pier, she finds herself sinking into a mire of bootlegging, smuggling, corruption—and an evil too dark to face.
All she wants is to find one dainty ladies’ glove. She doesn’t want to know why this merchant was on the wrong side of town—or why he was murdered in cold blood. But as she begins to see the connection between his murder, her father’s death, and the darkness plaguing the Westside, she faces the hard truth: she must save her city or die with it.
Introducing a truly remarkable female detective, Westside is a mystery steeped in the supernatural and shot through with gunfights, rotgut whiskey, and sizzling Dixieland jazz. Full of dazzling color, delightful twists, and truly thrilling action, it announces the arrival of a remarkable talent.
The premise of Westside sounded fascinating and I was very excited to read it. I like historical fantasy with a mystery. Actually I like mystery, period. Somehow, even though this had all the parts I should like, it wasn’t for me. The beginning had the detailed world-building which gave me a bit of first book syndrome when I feel like I don’t know or understand enough. It’s set in 1921 but this is an alternate sort of universe. It does feel like the time around Prohibition.
The main character Gilda is smart and brave. She has a wide knowledge about the people and happenings, partly because her father was a detective. But even so, she wasn’t clued into everything. The real issue is I didn’t feel I knew her or the other characters enough to care what happened to them.
The mystery was well plotted with enough twists and turns it wasn’t obvious to solve. Plus the paranormal factors added to the inability to predict what would happen. It felt slow for me, but really, others may enjoy it.
- 🎧 The Kind Worth Saving by Peter Swanson @PeterSwanson3 #KeithSzarabaijka #KathleenEarly #HelenLaser @MickyShiloah @HarperAudio #LoveAudiobooks - March 26, 2023
- Sunday Post –26 March 2023 @kimbacaffeinate @readingreality - March 26, 2023
- Conquer the Kingdom by Jennifer Estep @Jennifer_Estep @HarperVoyagerUS@avonbooks @LaurenFortgang#LoveAudiobooks - March 23, 2023
Reading this book contributed to these challenges:
- 2019 Releases
I’m still on the fence about this one. Great review, Anne. And I do love that cover.
I love the cover, the premise and I was so excited to read it. Somehow it wasn’t that exciting for me. I’m not sorry I read it but it wasn’t a fit.
What are you rating it? Too bad this wasn’t a better reading experience.
Well I left off the rating but I gave it a 3 on Goodreads. I guess. It wasn’t a bad book it just wasn’t for me.
I plan on getting to this one soon. I won a copy off of Goodreads. Have you read A Criminal Magic? It’s a wonderful historical book with magical elements. I keep looking for a book I love as much as that one. It’s a stand alone (much to my disappointment) and I really loved it!
I have not read A Criminal Magic. I’ll have to look into it. I hope you enjoy it!
It’s complicated when you can’t connect with the characters…
Yes that’s just it. The story wasn’t bad but I didn’t feel enough.
The cover really caught my eye. I’m sorry it didn’t turn out like you’d hoped. Better luck with your next one.
Melanie @ Hot Listens & Books of My Heart
That’s ok. Everything is not going to be everyone’s favorite. That would be boring.